The 2024-25 season has featured some breakout and moderate hits.
With continued changes plaguing the broadcast networks, there are far more metrics to consider than a few years ago.
Check out the current status of the 2024-2025 freshman class.
Shifting Gears – Likely Renewal
The Tim Allen-fronted comedy has become ABC’s highest-rated series in the demo in live + same day results.
Season-to-date, it is pulling in around 4.6 million viewers and a 0.43 rating in the demo.
The numbers have cooled off in recent weeks, but there’s no reason to believe it won’t be a part of the network’s 2025-2026 slate.
With The Conners ending, Shifting Gears could be a great companion for Abbott Elementary.
High Potential – Renewed
High Potential started slow in the fall, but viewers have been checking out the show via delayed viewing, making it one of ABC’s most-watched and highest-rated series when all platforms are factored in.
Given the impressive results, there were questions about a backorder.
However, the season remained capped at 13 episodes, likely due to Kaitlin’s commitment to It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia.
Still, the series has secured a renewal for next season, which may feature an expanded episode order.
Doctor Odyssey – Could Go Either Way
The Joshua Jackson cruise ship medical drama had a big promotional campaign, so it’s surprising the series has underperformed in the ratings.
ABC is trying to boost its numbers in the second half of the season with a two-part shark-attack-themed midseason premiere and a 9-1-1 crossover.
9-1-1 is a dominant force in the ratings, so the hope will be to send the numbers upward.
But we’re not convinced it will secure a renewal unless it gets a considerable boost.
Watson – Could Go Either Way
CBS’s new offering has a stellar cast, led by Morris Chestnut, but it doesn’t use any of them very well.
Despite solid initial viewership, the numbers have fallen, and the series is tracking behind its timeslot predecessor, The Equalizer, in the demo.
Given that CBS effectively sacrificed The Equalizer, the network clearly expected much better.
It’s a toss-up right now, but the next few episodes will decide the series’ fate.
Georgie and Mandy’s First Marriage – Renewed
By this point, we’ve learned never to count out The Big Bang Theory franchise, and Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage is proving the naysayers wrong.
The spinoff is putting up numbers just behind what sire Young Sheldom managed last season.
It should be a CBS mainstay for the years to come.
Matlock – Renewed
Reboots may be fizzling out left, right, and center, but Matlock is an example of a reboot done right.
It has a compelling plot that pays homage to the original and a must-watch lead in Kathy Bates.
The numbers have been miraculous and signal a long and happy future.
NCIS: Origins – Renewed
The latest entry in the NCIS franchise hasn’t set the ratings on fire, but it has pulled in enough viewership to secure another season.
The franchise’s decision to return to the past has allowed it to create its most cost-effective series because it doesn’t rely on returning stars to keep the story going.
CBS is high on the NCIS franchise and wants to keep it around for long.
Poppa’s House – Could Go Either Way
Poppa’s House has been a moderate performer for CBS, but it did secure a five-episode backorder. That’s usually a good sign.
However, the network has yet to commit to another season, despite making decisions about many other scripted series in late February.
With a Neighborhood spinoff in the mix for next season, the network may want to proceed with that and nix Poppa’s House.
Brilliant Minds – Could Go Either Way
The medical drama genre experienced a resurgence during the 2024-2025 season, but Brilliant Minds‘ on-air numbers didn’t quite reach a level that guaranteed a renewal.
However, it benefits from solid post-airdate viewing, which puts it above The Irrational, Law & Order, and Found, so there is a case for renewal.
But it will all come down to whether NBC wants to try something new post-The Voice.
The Hunting Party – Could Go Either Way
The 10 p.m. timeslot is tough, but The Hunting Party loses a lot of The Voice lead-in, which is never a good sign.
However, the series is still in its infancy, so we must wait for more ratings data.
But our first impressions are not good. Given the marketing, it should be doing better, but again, the 10 p.m. timeslots across the broadcast networks are struggling to keep up the pace.
St. Denis Medical – Renewed
St. Denis Medical has been one of NBC’s stronger scripted shows in live and same-day metrics, currently pacing ahead of Law & Order.
The network has had some trouble with comedies in recent years, but this mockumentary is proving resilient.
It will be interesting to see whether it keeps its usual slot next season or if NBC makes Fridays its only comedy block.
Happy’s Place – Renewed
Reba McEntire’s return to primetime TV in Happy’s Place helped considerably improve NBC’s Friday night schedule.
Comedies have been few and far between on the broadcast networks in recent years, so it’s interesting that two on one network have been renewed so soon.
Maybe the broadcast networks aren’t as dead as the media would like us to believe.
Suits LA – Likely Cancellation
Suits LA has aired only two episodes, and the numbers have not been encouraging.
Given the big hoo-ha about bringing the franchise back, 2.6 million viewers and a 0.24 rating will not keep the lights on very long. Even worse, it lost a million viewers in its second week.
Apparently, the offshoot did well on Peacock, but this has got to be a little frustrating for NBC.
Maybe Peacock would have been the better home all along.
Grosse Pointe Garden Society – Likely Cancellation
Despite airing two episodes alongside Suits, this Desperate Housewives-meets-How to Get Away with Murder drama got off the ground with 1.8 million viewers and a – gasp – 0.17 rating.
Unless the numbers miraculously turn around in the next few weeks, it will be the unwanted plant in NBC’s garden.
It’s a shame because the series has some fun elements, but it could be due to a lack of promotion. It popped up out of nowhere.
Rescue Hi-Surf – Likely Renewal
The series is clearly an attempt to fill the void left by the 9-1-1 franchise, and it works quite well.
The numbers amount to around 3.5 million and a 0.4 rating with a week of DVR factored in, which is enough to make it one of the network’s top dramas.
It should be renewed.
Murder in a Small Town – Renewed
The Kristen Kreuk crime drama was one of broadcast’s least-watched newbies, with an average of just over 3 million viewers and a 0.24 rating.
However, expectations were not as significant because it was a co-production with a Canadian broadcaster.
As a result, a renewal was expected, and our prayers were answered earlier this year.
Doc – Renewed
On the surface, Doc may seem like a mediocre performer.
In live + same-day ratings, it is averaging around 2.3 million viewers. In the demo, it’s doing around a 0.24 rating.
But FOX shocked everyone in February when it ordered a 22-episode second season.
Such high episode orders were thought to be a thing of the past, but the show performed very well digitally, compelling the network to take the plunge and double down.
Over to you, TV Fanatics! What are your thoughts on the freshman series status update?
TV Fanatic is searching for passionate writers to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.